Post by Host Damien on Jan 14, 2014 21:54:20 GMT -5
Survival Challenge Results #1
I'd like to start these by saying that both tribes did AMAZING!! You all worked very hard on your camps and I loved watching both tribes' progress! However, there can only be ONE winner! Your photos were judged by four past players who will remain anonymous and myself.
The other judges don't know about teamwork so they were only judging you on everything else. I will be the one judging you on your teamwork. The tribe with the most overall points will win Survival and will be safe from Judgement. Before we begin, lets look at your finished products…
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Originality [10 points] ~ Is it just a picture of the woods or does it have flavor?
Appeal [10 points] ~ Is it neat? Are there mindless cuts or awkward pictures? Does it look realistic?
Teamwork [10 points] ~ Did everyone partake in the challenge?
Effort [10 points] ~ Did you put it together at the last second or did you really try?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Judge #1
Nyoka
Originality: [9]
•Not the most original new world idea…but damn that gif flag adds some points.
Appeal: [7]
•Sophie's arm is apparently amputated lol.
Effort: [9]
TOTAL: [24]
Panya
Originality: [8]
•Well that's certainly a more original idea?
Appeal: [4]
•Those images are blurry and look poor.
Effort: [7]
TOTAL: [19]
Judge #2
Nyoka
Originality: [10]
•I like how you all look and you;re building a new world after a huge apocalypse I can see and understand the whole concept I like it and the waving flag gives it something extra.
Appeal: [8]
•I think it looks realistic, I like how Vecepia is screaming at the rat and Chelsea is about to kill one. They did a great job.
Effort: [9]
TOTAL: [27]
Panya
Originality: [8]
•At first I was a little confused, not sure why you're on the moon but since it's the apocalypse who knows what the world would look like so I understand it.
Appeal: [7]
•I like the concept of the photo but some peoples heads look a little weird.
Effort: [9]
•I can tell alot of effort has been put into this photo I mean I like the outter space theme so I'm gonna give you a high score on this
TOTAL: [24]
Judge #3
Nyoka
Originality: [9]
Appeal: [8]
Effort: [8]
TOTAL: [25]
Panya
Originality: [9]
Appeal: [4]
Effort: [7]
TOTAL: [21]
Judge #4
Nyoka
Originality: [8]
•Creativity is a 10 for sure. Loving the way it's all put together. It really feels like they're out there, surviving the apocalypse. And that animated flag is perfection! The originality of it though...gotta take off 2 points. There's nothing new about this apocalypse or survival.
Appeal: [8]
•I really like this photo cause you can tell who does what at camp and can imagine their daily lives. lol The flag really pulls you in and the scene keeps you for a while. The only reason it isn't higher is because I feel like they could've done more with this, to keep your focus.
Effort: [10]
•Looking for the right photos, cutting them into place so perfectly and the gif work....mwah! Simply amazing. My hat's off to the artist. *tips hat*
TOTAL: [26]
Panya
Originality: [9]
•Creativity is a 7 for me. It really made me go whaaaattt? lol I want to know more about this story and why everything is so purple. lol I like that they stepped out of the box. It's original enough for me to add 2 points to this category, making it a score of 9.
Appeal: [6]
•Other than the purple galore and randomly being in space...I'm not sure how this is apocolypse appropriate or how they think they'll survive in these conditions. They have no air, no water, no food and those oxygen tanks will only last a short time. Even if we ignore the fact these people have no helmets on and should already be dead...these people would die within a day. The only thing keeping MY appeal...is the giant structure in the back and all the purple. Remove those 2 items...and I'd have no interest in this.
Effort: [8]
•Effort, I'm torn on. I feel like they put in a lot of effort, but at the same time...they reused the same pictures over and over again with the suits & tanks. I'll give it an 8.
TOTAL: [23]
Judge #5
Nyoka
Originality: [8]
Appeal: [8]
Teamwork: [10]
Effort: [9]
•I am very impressed with how well you worked together! This finished product was impeccable and the waving flag was so creative! You put a lot into this challenge and I am very happy with it! You should definitely be proud of yourselves. There are a few minor, awkward cuts here and there but not too bad. Overall, great job!
TOTAL: [35]
Panya
Originality: [9]
Appeal: [6]
Teamwork: [10]
Effort: [9]
•WOW! Talk about creative! I really like how you came up with a unique idea. And everything in the finished product works with your theme. There are some awkward cuts in yours as well but, again, minor. Your tribe worked VERY well together!! Again, a great job!!
TOTAL: [34]
Again, congrats to both tribes for making GREAT finished products. However, only one can come out victorious! The winner of the first Survival Challenge is...
NYOKA
Congratulations, Nyoka!! Your flag was AWESOME! And because of that, you have won Survival this first round.
As for you, Panya ~ you should be proud of yourselves but you have lost this challenge. You will now be heading to Judgement where the first person will be voted out of this game.
